As anticipated, Shadow was significantly distressed after the program. After being strung up Shadow bit the female with whom he was then living. Shadow was returned to the rescue he originated from. The rescue learnt that the scene where he bites Cesar they had actually been working him up for an hour prior to they got that clip. They intentionally bait the pets to get them to respond, it is everything about the program and not the pet.
This clip demonstrates how aversive methods can result in found out vulnerability. Discovered vulnerability, or ‘closed down’, typically gets puzzled with a ‘calm submissive’ state. In a state of discovered vulnerability, the signs are surpressed (frequently by penalty) which is why the pet stops acting out. It appears like a fast repair, however it’s a fallacious and unsafe service to the bothersome habits.
And who are you to question cesar? I'm no sheep I've done my own research I've seen most of cesars training and his success rate is amazing. The rope lead is like that that a reason so the dog learns not to pull. The leesh had to tension at all until the dog pulled. It's a learning curve
Is anyone else just dumbfounded? Yhis is the only bad video I’ve ever seen of Caesar
Suddenly everyone is a dog psychology expert.
This video is fucking stupid. Cesar is doing an excellent job. This dog was on the verge of being put to sleep.
As a military man ive been choked out many times. THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT HAPPENED.The dog was responding fine, then attacked the LEASH, NOT THE HOLDER.In the end with the choke collar he literally choked him out, like I said I've experienced it many times it can happen fast if you properly cut the blood to the brain its 15 seconds and your out before you realize and run out of air. IMPROPERLY your killing the person/dog like here and your drowning them, fight instinct sets in as you/they suffer. When you do blackout your confused and loopy unaware of your surroundings for a while if you come to this fast. I've been there both ways, been choked out then released the moment you go black you can just face plant on the ground but come aware like youve had 30 beers just foggy and like “WTF is going on”. Thats what that dog is experiencing, Flight or fight fear of being murdered then confusion like a drunk person laying on the floor.I would hope more people see this, the “Kick” alone is crime as animal abuse but im 100% sure the owners signed legal documents releasing them prior to filming.
That is a 100% euthanize dog people here thinking you can train that dog with pure love and hugs are fucking morons and bad owners, that's not even a spiked prong collar the dog is not looking for an exit doesn't move around to say he wants to go away he sits there and confronts cesar that is pure aggression not fear, a healthy dog does not choke himself they stop immediately that dog is likely to have attacked and even kill the other dog if not leashed
Criticism without an alternative solution causes putting pets to sleep.
Most of the pet owner abandons their pets because of unwanted behaviors or puts pets to sleep (gently killing the animals).
Is it possible to find a better methodology better Cesar Milan with proof?
Doubtful!
What a load of crock !….any time you get someone who genuinely loves animals and knows how to help them …you run them into the ground ..this is a wolf hybrid do you know how dangerous they can be instinctively?…this is why people shouldnt own them because they are not strong enough to cope with them …cesar looked after dogs long before he got on tv….so to say he puts them in this state and has himself attacked and bitten for the good of some tv show is bull…how can you even know that ..every explanation you give on this animals behaviour is wrong ..the hyperventilation is from pent up aggression and pulling and the dog is pulling itself …these are reactions …same as a sneeze when playing with a dog is their brains snapping themselves out of playing rough or attacking ….what a shitty video..
You are totally ignorant… go to mommy… and let her call PETA.
I mean nothing wrong using a herm sprenger prong collar but that was unnecessary excessive force. It's a correction collar to be used when the dog shows behavior you don't like and its a quick snap (no need to jerk the dog around the street). When the dog shows the correct behavior, you praise/treat. He aint doing any of that. I feel like cesar misses the good cop/bad cop aspect of dog training. Its always punishment.
Training a dog with treats works too but what happens when you don’t have any cookies and the dog is going after another dog, or person, or child? I guess we just run to the kitchen to get a cookie 🍪 and wave it in their face hoping the dog will let go of the victim? In a pack, that dog would have been dealt with in exactly the same way if not worse, with the teeth and claws of the whole pack, instead of a single man with a collar. 👍🏽
Me – Breeding malamutes for decades. Cezar´s method is OK in case of such agressivity. Who doesn´t know mals, should be educated about them. Agressivity is nothing what they born with. This dog had to be forced for unadequate training for malamutes (f.e. defence training etc). Or was very badly behaved by his owner. He is angry, desoriented, insecure. He doesn´t want to be leader! He was forced by stupid modern methods to be “partner”. What a missunderstanding. Shame on people who wants malamute and don´t know anything about them.
How many times we (breeders of mals) have to do the same? Because of stupid owners, who let the malamute do anything what HE wants. I runned malamute rescue for 15 years so many poor mals devalved by stupid owners – followers of training modern methods. Malamute is the oldest breed ever – no modern ethical methods are recommended. Please give the facts about mals together and use critical sense of reason.
Victoria would beat his ass over this lmao
This man is vile and his techniques are wholly unnecessary and extremely violent. This could have killed the dog due to the stress caused by his “training”, not to mention the fact this is just torture and is not in any way an effective method for training. It teaches the dog pain comes from men with leashes, wouldn't be surprised if his behaviour gets worse over time and if his life is actually shortened due to the stress put on his body.
a lot of things wrong with this, i suppose the dog hasn’t been desensitized to other dogs in the beginning so this is extremely wrong, i suppose the dog also hasn’t been introduced properly to pressure training or first slip leads than prongs because i know that takes time and i bet cesar just saw the dog a couple days prior or even the same day. i admit to not seeing the whole episode but just by the first minute of this video and with the dog responding to the prong it’s obvious it’s misused, please do proper research and get with a reputable and professional dog trainer to use tools and just because someone famous is using it it doesn’t mean they use it properly, dogs should train with prongs only when necessary and after properly introduced to first leash pressure and corrections, after that slip lead pressure and than in a safe environment prongs after that continue to slowly work forward to the situation cesar got shadow into
years ago i had a 138lb Malalmute/Wolf his mom was 94% Grey wolf and he was great with family and kids but never ever good with other dogs, he was always so Dominate
“Those who don’t deal with dogs who bite should not delve into the discussion of how best to handle the situation. Just like those who don’t know about medicine should not offer medical advice.”
I watched this full episode. Your captions are incorrect and 100% your OPINION. That dog was a RED ZONED. Which means if he doesn't get trained, he gets euthanized because he's so dangerous. He attacked his owner multiple times during walks, wanted to kill the neighbor dog and mauled Ceasar. Casear put that dog in his place like he needed to be.
You say that Cesar was being unfair by setting the dog up for failure, but the dogs condition and goals for recovery were a setup for failure as well. Firstly, the dog should have been gradually introduced to corrective behaviors and stressful behaviors from a younger age. A full grown dog completely unfamiliar with the discipline under stress will of course be dangerous. Undoubtedly, Shadow is very scared yes, but he also is using agression over fear, not fighting despite fear. When Cesar choked Shadow, that was in self defense. If he were repeatedly retry the same thing over and over it would certainly be abuse, but Cesar is trying to implement different methods gradually. There is no way for Cesar to fully know what will and will not work, he did not purposefully cause any harm to the animal, rather he was doing his best to protect himself and Shadow while also trying to find the best way to correct behaviors that had become natural to Shadow by continually experiencing the stressor without having any corrective training.
That dog is lucky to have found Cesar or it would be dead by now
Wow that's not fair to judge him on a species he's not trained to handle.
It's funny how they call expert to vets, who barely know about the real animal behavior and education 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Lmao cry harder dude. Cesar is the best. Stay mad
leash pressure can be such a great training tool when used correctly. this is just abuse. choking the dog with two different collars, having it on a tight leash while the dog is doing good behavior, and just forcing the dog into that situation without even attempting to start from the ground and work his way up to having the dogs that close. im shocked that people like this man
The captions say “it’s important to never let the dog practise unwanted behaviour” … that’s not how reality works. Does the owner have to move to the desert? But yes the dog couldn’t bark because it was choking. You see Cesar kick their bums and strike their haunches to shock them into compliance. Some dogs rose to meet the aggressor. That’s when you have to change tactic
I hate this guy with such a burning passion because he just takes dogs and abuses them on camera, all the while talking absolute bullshit that's totally incorrect
Him fighting for his life is the saddest thing I've seen in a long time
How not to use a training tool and how not to train a dog when someone asks u how to train a dog just do the opposite of wut this guy is doing
Que cena horrível, tão triste
That dogs tongue was purple… he was gasping for air. That’s not ok. That can cause so many health problems
just a minute in and those noises that poor dog was making screamed as if he were in pain. the only aggression was in defence and wasnt offensive at all.
Shadow is doing good in his new home now. No one will ever hurt him like this again.
Turns out the producers also force the dog to give reactions on the shows. They mess with the dog for a half hour to an hour and keep walking by their reactants and pulling on the leash so when they film the show the dog is already worked up and upset
We should use the same description about this dog fighting the process of being suffocated to when describing black men fighting for their lives when the police attack.
I would lose it if he did this to my dog
hes an ass
“Calm him down” Slip leads will NEVER calm a dog down. He also used the fact Shadow has wolf in him? With BASIC knowledge you know the breed won't affect a dog at that level. I'm sorry Shadow had to deal with all of this, poor baby.
If you don't put the dog in a situation of showing the behavior you don't want you can't correct that behavior. These methods are the only way to establish dominance. And you HAVE to be the dominant one in any animal human relationship or it will fail. Simple as that, and someone will get hurt. He never “hung” the dog by any means at all. People are way too sensitive, stop being such a bitch about everything and just trying to find stuff to complain and bitch about.
Obviously those who commented bad things are the ones who has ptoblematic dogs! Lol! Haters gon hate 😆😆😆
This is SO hard to watch I don’t understand how anyone with EYES cannot see signs of a dog struggling to breathe
I’m disgusted
As a trainer I would never put a dog in a position where they’re uncomfortable. Period.
its so easy every body talking shit about any one who ative some thing that matters…if any body here nevers go wrong on some thing so we are already on heavens…so easy to judge some body !!!
@jkvl jkvl….I've never seen jealousy look good on anyone…ever. Have you?
I wish that dog had bitten cesar so bad, he could never work with dogs again. Yes, I know that might end with Shadow being killed but he would have saved so many dogs from Cesar's abuse
Your narrations are covering the very exact scenes you want the audience to focus on 🧐
i use prong collars with dogs who respond to quick correction or occasional pulling. this is NOT what a prong collar is safely used for.
he almost killed that dog. this is gross.
Cesar go back to selling chorrizos
Oh hell no , they would need an ambulance to pick his sorry but up after I got done with him . You do not treat animals this way. From the show I thought he maybe a good trainer but after all the behind the scenes videos I see now all he did was intimidate the animals.
He’s literally abusing that poor dog..
Yeah let's also understand that Cesar isn't God he's a human he also make mistakes with some dogs but most importantly he never wanted to harm any dog he just wanted to help
I understand some say balanced training is good but this is way to far
All you internet experts cannot even achieve 1% of what he does. Post videos of where you have gone from a before and after – easy to throw stones.
This makes me sick made me lose complete respect for this guy
2:40, look at Shadow's face. If the dog you're training ever shows an expression like that during a session u should probably quit. Jfc
And I get bit the dog had a flat collar one a hurt her self so ehat was i doing worng
I like the complaints on how this was handled. The dog is dangerous. Just put it down.
I agree this is abuse but wtf are u gonna fo when an 100 pound dog with a bite force of 300 pounds
Omggg what a cruel sick bastard literally strangling that poor dog. And in the vicinity of pushing way over threshold in close proximity to another dog. This guy needs to be charged with animal cruelty. This is heart breaking.
I can't believe THIS man is famous for being dog “psychologist”. He knows nothing about dogs, empathy and humanity.It was so painful to watch. HOW THE HELL OWNERS DIDN'T NOTICE THEIR DOG WAS FIGHTING FOR ITS LIFE
amazing …all these experts in the comments yet all I run into on my walks is bad owners with aggressive dogs.
Maybe he shouldn’t be allowed to train dogs anymore. I would definitely not let him touch mine. He should stick to training cats, see how that goes
Shame on you Cesar!
Okay so what would you do in his shoes
The Dummkopf that made this Videos has no knowledge of dogs.
I would love to see how you people will fix this problem!?Let me tell you how would you do it you will actually beat him up then to the shelter
Everyone saying he ain't a trained professional is fucking stupidNo one wit a actual license to train ever called out ceaser only motherfuckers wit hating ass yt channels
that's him kicking a dog..?
Good intentions on the video, but the only information that wasn’t biased useless crap was the third to last text on screen
What a vile, disgusting man. What is described above and shown in the video is the behavior of a sociopath. I don't know of any other way to describe him.
Cesar is GOD. This video has been disproven & discredited innumerable times. You have to be the PACK LEADER like Cesar. You rock Cesar!!!🤘
Wow 😕
Where’s all the Millan fanboys to talk about achieveing dominance through strangulation
Why did he kick him?! What was his excuse? Ugh that was so hard to watch
And people support this guy..
Don't believe any of this.
He doesn't even sound confident in what he's saying.
If you have seen the full Video you know the Dog has thhe same problem by his owners or the owners has the same Problem with the Dog an don't forget, that they have Kids at home. So the dog continually swing his rod. The dog was aggressive and dominant to every Human in this Situation like Cesar was.Please watch the full episode.
this is honestly disturbing and hard to watch. thank you for sharing this. up to now i'd had a much better impression of mr millan and this video was eye opening. if there's one positive aspect to this it is that, today, mr millan is a legitimately good trainer, and probably the world's best. even if he made mistakes years ago such as this (and let's acknowledge he was a clueless IDIOT here), it slowly built him into the trainer he is today, and his high skill level has saved the lives of many dogs. further more, he shares all his techniques that do work with the world.so that's the positive aspect to this. however, there is no doubt that this video is disturbing, and he was doing everything wrong.
I couldn’t even finish watching it because it was soo upsetting.
Thankyou for sharing this. My nephew is autistic and believes that Cesar Milan's way is the only way to train a dog. He will not listen to any other methods or theories. I told him about this incident, and he was shocked to hear it. Tomorrow I'll be able to show him precisely why Cesar can go fuck himself.
The sad thing is, given that this dog was able to sit a few feet away from another dog he was supposedly freaking out at…means this situation could have been handled without any violence and simply by distracting the dog as it prepares to freak out.My own girl is a malice at the leash at times, but if you break/avert her attention then she can go through the situation with just a bit of huffing and puffing. No choking or prong collar needed, just attention and care from the other end of the leash. It may not fix things, but it's a start. And surely a better one than hanging a dog and just causing it to have additional problems to the ones it already had to begin with…
You Can see how the dog is trying to breath while he is hunging him the worst trainer ever
the way he didn’t even attempt to notice the dog jumping up and repeatedly grabbing the leash meant it’s getting choked out goes to show how much he truly cared about those dogs
I hate this cuz if you use a prong collar correctly, it’s not supposed to hurt the dog at all. And the fact that he switched to a more cruel version than just putting a normal collar or head harness on the dog is just ridiculous…
No wonder this channel has 51 subcribers… its blatent false and edited to show a narrative you choose… also putting writing up on the screen as if its fact when its just your own dumbass opinion… you might have lured a few idiots with this tactic but it obviously is a few judging by your subs .. also I've more respect for people who criticised cesar in a balanced way ( might not agree with them) but at least they were doing it in good faith… this is a very pathethic attempt to just get views and offer no information yourself.. how convenient for you to try n destroy someone's reputation while offering no alternative or any opinion at all… bottom feeder go get a life. How is this educational? Why arent you putting yourself in similar scenarios to see how you deal with it? Can i see you in action with an aggresive dog? Or any dog? No thought not you're typing shit instead of doing anything… you TYPED LOOK AT THAT PRONG COLLAR ON HIS NECK yet in the very next sentence cesar says he wants it removed… I've NEVER EVER seen him suggest a prong collar. He walks into the situation with WHAT THE OWNERS ARE USING… also a slip leash is widely used , you trying to give it the choke collar name to provoke people is ridiculous… pleaze I'd love to see you take on a very aggressive dog or any dog.. looking forward to your video??? dimbass
You can see how terrified he is of the dog. That fucking idiot needs to get canceled
why so many disagree with your video lol…I seen him and for my experience with dogs he has great handling with dogs, not perfect but never saw someone like him in years.
wow all the comments and judgements from people who probably dont even have dogs or know the first thing about training dogs. you're all soft as baby shit!! he did not kick the dog my god he used his foot to lightly nudge the dogs bottom side. the dog was not fighting for its life .. how rediculous you all sound. so tell me all you experts. if you shouldnt put your dog in a situation where you can correct the bad behavior .. how will your dog learn not to engage in the bad behavior?
I hope someone puts a slip collar on this bloody joker and give him a taste of his own medicine.
And I love the addition of modern science. What they don't tell you is that modern scientific experiments never work with dogs that are extreme cases because they cannot run safe experiments on them. So their experiments they are running around Labradoodle mixes that are easy to work with and not truly dominant dogs! Go read the studies for yourself and they will tell you the disclaimer of the dogs that could not participate in the study because of their aggression
There is training a dog, then there is breaking, humiliating, and abusing a dog and framing as you training them. Any person with logic can clearly see that Shadow is being choked, the way his back legs move is a clear sign of disorientation and nearing unconsciousness.
All these complaints are because we see the dogs human babies.Just imagine Cesar as the lead dog correcting the dogs behaviour. We don't have a problem when an older dog corrects a younger dog through a bite. It's their way/ nature.So imagine Cesar's leash/ fingers/ leg as the lead dogs teeth. Then you'll realize he's just using the dog's natural ways to correct behavior which is the easiest way for them to learn.